Archivist Page Review

Review parser variants for one source page, compare outputs, and jump directly to the source evidence.

Document: 14 A Study of Northwestern Apples

Source page: Open page 12 in document reader

Institution: Open PRAIRIE | Publisher: | Year: | Pages: 144

Source URL: https://openprairie.sdstate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1075&context=agexperimentsta_bulletins

Selected Versions

Left: archivist-1.6.68-spark (fragment 5675)

Right: archivist-1.0 (fragment 3336)

Next Step

Reprocess/promote controls are the next UI layer. The data foundation is now versioned and diffable.

Page Version Diff

Cultivars Added

Anis
Charlamoff
Christmas
Cross
Duchess
Golden White
Hibernal
Ostrakoff
Repka Malenka
Romna
Yellow Sweet
Yellow Transparent

Claims Added

Anis | taxon_context | Anis is one of the fourteen groups defined and described by the commission.
Anisim | recommendation_context | A. G. Tuttle included Anisim among the best six varieties he had tested, in order of value.
Anisim | taxon_context | Anisim is one of the fourteen groups defined and described by the commission.
Antonovka | recommendation_context | A. G. Tuttle included Antonovka among the best six varieties he had tested, in order of value.
Antonovka | taxon_context | Antonovka is one of the fourteen groups defined and described by the commission.
Arabskoe | description_snippet | Arabskoe is one of ten varieties for which descriptions were adopted because of special attention in the northwest.
Beautiful Arcade | description_snippet | Beautiful Arcade is one of ten varieties for which descriptions were adopted because of special attention in the northwest.
Beautiful Arcade | flavor_profile | A. G. Tuttle identified Beautiful Arcade as the sweet variety in his ranked best-six list.
Beautiful Arcade | recommendation_context | A. G. Tuttle included Beautiful Arcade among the best six varieties he had tested, in order of value.
Bode | description_snippet | Bode is one of ten varieties for which descriptions were adopted because of special attention in the northwest.
Charlamoff | taxon_context | Charlamoff is one of the fourteen groups defined and described by the commission.
Christmas | taxon_context | Christmas is one of the fourteen groups defined and described by the commission.
Cross | taxon_context | Cross is one of the fourteen groups defined and described by the commission.
Duchess | taxon_context | Duchess is one of the fourteen groups defined and described by the commission.
Golden White | taxon_context | Golden White is one of the fourteen groups defined and described by the commission.
Hibernal | recommendation_context | The commission selected Hibernal as the best representative of the Hibernal group and dropped the others from the lists for the present.
Hibernal | taxon_context | Hibernal is treated as the official name representing a group of related Russian apples.
Long Arcade | description_snippet | Descriptions were adopted for Long Arcade as one of ten varieties attracting special attention in the northwest.
Longfield | productivity | A. G. Tuttle described Longfield as a great annual bearer.
Longfield | recommendation_context | A. G. Tuttle named Longfield first in order of value among the best six varieties he had tested.

Figures Added

none

Citations Added

none

Cultivars Removed

Ostraxoff

Claims Removed

Anisim | recommendation_context | Included as one of A. G. Tuttle's top six tested varieties.
Antonovka | recommendation_context | Included as one of A. G. Tuttle's top six tested varieties.
Arabskoe | selection_origin_reference | Listed among the ten additional varieties adopted for northwest special attention.
Beautiful Arcade | flavor_profile | Described by A. G. Tuttle as "for sweet."
Beautiful Arcade | recommendation_context | Ranked within Tuttle's tested best six list.
Beautiful Arcade | selection_origin_reference | Adopted among the ten additional varietal entries for northwest interest.
Bode | selection_origin_reference | Adopted by the commission as a varietal entry of special interest for northwest coverage.
Long Arcade | selection_origin_reference | Included among ten additional varieties adopted because they attracted special attention in the northwest.
Longfield | description_snippet | Noted as "a great annual bearer."
Longfield | recommendation_context | Ranked first among A. G. Tuttle's six best tested varieties.
Lowland Raspberry | recommendation_context | Appears in A. G. Tuttle's best-six tested set as "Lowland" (likely referring to Lowland Raspberry; text truncated).
Lowland Raspberry | selection_origin_reference | Listed in the ten additional varietal entries adopted for northwest attention.
Lubsk Queen | selection_origin_reference | Identified as an additional varietal inclusion because it drew special attention in northwest trials.
Ostraxoff | selection_origin_reference | Adopted among ten northwest special-attention varieties.
Sweet Longfield | selection_origin_reference | Included in the ten-variety set adopted for northwest attention.
Vargulek | selection_origin_reference | Adopted as one of the ten additional northwest special-interest varietal entries.
Zuzoff | selection_origin_reference | Part of the commission-adopted set of ten varieties with special attention in northwest conditions.

Figures Removed

none

Citations Removed

"The numbers indicating size of fruit are according to the scale adopted by the American Pomological Society."

Available Page Versions

ID	Variant	Status	Model	Specialization	Counts	Source	Compare
1592	archivist-1.6.68-spark	active	gpt-5.3-codex-spark	visual_page_generalist	13 cultivars / 17 claims / 0 figures	Open source page
512	archivist-1.0	baseline_promoted	gpt-5.4	visual_page_generalist	24 cultivars / 32 claims / 0 figures	Open source page	Compare to active