Dashboard Explore Search Sources Source Graph Ingest Rights Review Translations Translation QA Publish Review Publish Export Revisit Campaigns History History Conflicts History Arbitration Review Queue Charts Taxa Taxonomy Tree Cultivars Lineage Lab Climate Breeders Institutions Programs Compare Compare Tray Trait Matrix Names Nurseries Nurseries+Catalogs Catalog Issues Archivist Resolution Contradictions Arbitration About API Docs

Archivist Page Review

Review parser variants for one source page, compare outputs, and jump directly to the source evidence.

Document: 3 Edible Apples in Prairie Canada

Source page: Open page 46 in document reader

Institution: University of Saskatchewan Fruit Program | Publisher: | Year: | Pages: 79

Source URL: https://research-groups.usask.ca/fruit/documents/apples/Edible-Apples-in-Prairie-Canada1.pdf

Selected Versions

Left: archivist-1.2-dense-directory-codebook (fragment 5621)

Right: archivist-1.1-dense-directory (fragment 4219)

Next Step

Reprocess/promote controls are the next UI layer. The data foundation is now versioned and diffable.

Page Version Diff

Cultivars Added
  • Meecca
Claims Added
  • Martin | description_snippet | Note: not to be confused with the intro of the same name by Charles Martin (1943).
  • Martin | entry_pedigree | CEF (1930) from a cross of 1902 Duchess.
  • Martin | rootstock_compatibility | Also tried as a rootstock, but dropped due to narrow and misshapen crotches.
  • Marvel | selection_origin_reference | US trial 1972.
  • Mary Currelly | breeder_reference | V.T. Macoun, Ottawa.
  • Mary Currelly | fruit_size | Fruit 4 cm.
  • Max Trig | selection_origin_reference | Hansen intro; test at Morden (1956).
  • Mccloy | entry_location | John McCloy, Kristino, SK.
  • Mccloy | entry_pedigree | Russian sdlg.
  • Mccloy | fruit_color | Fruit yellow with slight blush.
  • Mccloy | keeping_quality | Does not keep.
  • Mccloy | productivity | Bears early. Productive.
  • Mccloy | release_year_reference | Intro by Wright (1948).
  • Mccloy | selection_origin_reference | Morden test, 1949.
  • Mccloy | source_reference_abbreviation | Ref Skinner's cat (1969).
  • Mccreary | entry_location | B.A. Telford, McCreary, MB.
  • Mccreary | release_year_reference | (1933).
  • Mcdonald | entry_location | T. Frankland, Stonewall, MB.
  • Mcdonald-Reid | entry_location | Dr McDonald-Reid, Lakeview Gardens, Silver Park, SK.
  • Mcdonald-Reid | release_year_reference | Skinner intro (1954).
Figures Added
  • none
Citations Added
  • CGS, WCSH (1949)
  • L&W
Cultivars Removed
  • Mecca
Claims Removed
  • Martin | breeder_reference | Associated with CEF (Central Experimental Farm, Ottawa) and dated 1930.
  • Martin | description_snippet | Listed as a standard apple (standard apple, fruit 5 cm diameter or more).
  • Martin | description_snippet | The entry warns not to confuse this cultivar with another introduction of the same name by Charles Martin in 1943.
  • Martin | entry_pedigree | Recorded as "Pioneer / Ontario" and noted as from a cross made in 1902.
  • Martin | rootstock_compatibility | Also tried as a rootstock, but dropped because of narrow and misshapen crotches.
  • Martin | taxon_context | Marked ST, meaning a standard apple with fruit 5 cm diameter or more.
  • Marvel | description_snippet | An apparent trial or test date around 1972 is noted, but the scan is uncertain.
  • Marvel | description_snippet | Listed as a standard apple (standard apple, fruit 5 cm diameter or more).
  • Marvel | selection_origin_reference | Origin noted as United States.
  • Marvel | taxon_context | Marked ST, meaning a standard apple with fruit 5 cm diameter or more.
  • Mary Currelly | breeder_reference | Associated with W.T. Macoun, Ottawa.
  • Mary Currelly | description_snippet | Listed as a crabapple (crabapple or applecrab, fruit less than 5 cm diameter).
  • Mary Currelly | fruit_size | Fruit about 4 cm in diameter.
  • Mary Currelly | selection_origin_reference | Origin is given as unknown.
  • Mary Currelly | taxon_context | Marked CR, meaning a crabapple or applecrab with fruit less than 5 cm diameter.
  • Max Trig | breeder_reference | Associated with Hansen.
  • Max Trig | description_snippet | Listed as a crabapple (crabapple or applecrab, fruit less than 5 cm diameter).
  • Max Trig | entry_location | On test at Morden in 1956.
  • Max Trig | taxon_context | Marked CR, meaning a crabapple or applecrab with fruit less than 5 cm diameter.
  • Mccloy | breeder_reference | Associated with John McCloy of Lintiston, Saskatchewan.
Figures Removed
  • none
Citations Removed
  • LdW
  • WCSH (1949)

Available Page Versions

IDVariantStatusModelSpecializationCountsSourceCompare
1542archivist-1.2-dense-directory-codebookactivegpt-5.4dense_directory_entry_list17 cultivars / 119 claims / 0 figuresOpen source page
1221archivist-1.1-dense-directorycandidategpt-5.4dense_directory_entry_list17 cultivars / 68 claims / 0 figuresOpen source pageCompare to active
80archivist-1.0baseline_promotedgpt-5.4visual_page_generalist17 cultivars / 64 claims / 0 figuresOpen source pageCompare to active